top of page

Can America Be Islamized?

Nov 12
5 min read
Can America Be Islamized? 62% identify as Christian, 1% are Muslim. Line drawing of an empty church pew.

Thursday morning. I open Instagram and a reel comes up: a senator-elect says he'll take his oath of office on the Quran. He hasn't picked which one. It might be the copy Thomas Jefferson owned. It might be a very old one kept at the University of Michigan.

The video had 85 comments. Nearly all of them asked the same thing in different words: are they taking the country from us?

I asked it too. So I went looking for the numbers.

The real size.

Pew Research surveyed 36,908 adults in 2023 and 2024. It's the largest religion survey in the country. 62% call themselves Christian. Muslim adults are about 1%.

Sixty-two to one.

Yes, they're growing. Across the U.S. and Canada they reached roughly 6 million by 2020, up 52% in ten years. Yes, they're young: median age 28, against 44 for Christians. And with all of that, Pew's projection for 2050 puts them at 2.1% of the population.

They double. They're still two in a hundred.

The variables, one at a time.

Six variables decide whether one religion displaces another in a country. I went through all six.

Immigration. 59% of Muslim adults here were born abroad. Their growth depends on a door Washington opens and shuts. And most of the people coming through that same door are Christians: 58% of immigrants.

Birth rate. Higher than average today. Demographers expect it to drift toward the national norm as American-born generations come up, the way it has for other immigrant groups.

Conversion. 23% of those raised Muslim in America no longer are. Nearly the same share of today's Muslims are converts. What comes in goes out. Conrad Hackett, Pew's senior demographer, says it of the whole world: Islam grows by births, very little by adults converting.

Retention. Of those who leave Islam here, 55% end up with no religion. 22% become Christian.

Law. The First Amendment bars the state from imposing any religion. Changing it takes two-thirds of Congress and 38 states.

Political power. This is the variable that lit up the reel. It gets its own section.

The politics that produces the conversation.

The question wasn't born in a mosque. It was born in a campaign.

The data is real. Before the November elections, CAIR counted 255 Muslim elected officials in 26 states: 98 city council members, 63 on school boards, 46 state legislators, 11 mayors. After November 3 it reported at least 97 wins. And Michigan elected the first Muslim senator in history.

That's a record. It's also this: the country has about half a million elected offices. In Congress there will be fewer than ten out of 535.

Each side works the number. One holds it up as proof of strength. The other holds it up as proof of invasion. The vice president called the senator-elect a representative of a terrible evil, and in January he's the one who swears him in. Fear moves votes. So does grievance. The word "Islamization" pays off for both at the ballot box, which is why it isn't going away.

Islamist groups with stated ambitions do exist, and outfits like the Middle East Forum track them closely. Watching is fine. Mistaking a New Jersey councilman for a caliphate is something else.

Looking away doesn't work for me either. A faith that checks out of public life lets others decide for it.

The threat that does have numbers.

This is where it hurt.

In 2007, 78% of the country called itself Christian. Today it's 62%. Sixteen points in seventeen years.

Those sixteen points didn't go to the mosque. They went to the box marked "none."

Ryan Burge, a political scientist at Washington University in St. Louis, read the same data and put it this way: for every six people who left the Christian faith, one came in. Among Gen Z, more than four in ten have no religion. Burge grants that the rise of the "nones" has stalled in recent years. He doesn't see revival in the tables. He sees a pause.

Pew modeled the country out to 2070 under four scenarios. Christians land between 35% and 54%. In the most likely one they drop below 50% around 2050. In none of the four does Islam show up as the replacement. In all four, the empty pew does.

I confess that when I looked at the situation I was filled with unease, and I hadn't opened a single table yet.

I confess it's easier to keep an eye on the neighbor than to check my own house.

I confess I know more arguments against Islam than names of Muslims.

Paul's spirit was stirred when he saw Athens full of idols, and what he did was go down to the marketplace and talk (Acts 17:16-17). Unease, carried well, walks.

What we can do.

Four things.

  1. Disciple at home. Moses commanded that the Word be repeated to the children sitting, walking, lying down, and getting up (Deut. 6:6-7). The sixteen points were lost right there, at the table.

  2. Know Islam firsthand. Read what the Quran says about Jesus. Ask a Muslim what he believes, and listen to the whole answer.

  3. Defend religious liberty, all of it. We Baptists fought for it when we were the ones being persecuted. The clause that lets a senator swear on his book is the same one that lets me open my Bible in the public square.

  4. Seat a Muslim at your table. Peter asks for a reason for the hope, given with gentleness (1 Pet. 3:15). Paul in Athens looked first, quoted what they knew, and then announced the resurrection (Acts 17:22-31). Neither one started by shouting.

Let me say all of it: our aim is to evangelize Muslims and bring them to Christ. Knowing them by name, seating them at the table, reading with them. All of it serves an active evangelism, so that they may know Christ and have eternal life.

The same principle holds for those who walked out of the church without opening any other door. Jesus said he is the way, the truth, and the life, and that no one comes to the Father except through him (John 14:6). Eternal life is through Christ. For the Muslim. For the one who left. For my children.

Burge doesn't see revival in the tables. He's right. Revivals never started in a table.

They started with a hundred and twenty people praying in an upper room, and one day three thousand were added (Acts 1:15; 2:41). No demographer had it projected.

Habakkuk asked for it with his country in ruins: Lord, revive your work in the midst of the years (Hab. 3:2). That prayer is still available. For the empty pew. For the mosque on the corner. For my house.

What if it starts at your table?

Sources

Comments


  • Instagram
  • Facebook
Gemini_Generated_Image_4xaha34xaha34xah_edited.jpg
bottom of page